Skip to content

2 Comments

  1. clarence collins
    20 June 2011 @ 8:37 pm

    People say that many hymns were put to tavern tunes. Is there any truth to this?

    • rcottrill
      21 June 2011 @ 9:16 am

      This is one of those “old chestnuts” sometimes used to excuse the use of contemporary secular rock stylings in the music of the church. I’d love to hear from the “people” who actually say this, and have them give me a list of the “many hymns” that have barroom tunes. (They wouldn’t be able to do it.) This Sunday I’ll be posting an article called “Barroom Tunes…Again!” discussing the subject in more detail. You may be able to access it now, here. If not, check the blog on Sunday (June 26/11). Meanwhile, the short answer is that this is a myth. One time I actually went through a hymn book, song by song (about 500 hymns), and hunted up the origin of each tune. The article will explain what I discovered.