Skip to content

3 Comments

  1. rhwoodman
    11 March 2015 @ 3:51 am

    I love this hymn, but I had never heard the story behind it. Thank you for this post.

    Reply

  2. Neil MacCormick
    19 March 2015 @ 6:01 pm

    A complete provenance surely must refer to the lyrics “Child In the Manger” which were used in the original setting of the beautiful melody, written in Scottish Gaelic by Mary M. MacDonald, a native of Bunessan.

    Reply

    • rcottrill
      20 March 2015 @ 7:08 am

      H-m-m… Well, I know that Bunessan was first published in 1888, in Songs and Hymns of the Gael, and appeared in the Irish Church Hymnal, in 1919 with the text you mention. I do try to be as accurate as I can about the hymns and their tunes However, my focus has never been on the latter, but on how the themes dealt with in the words reflect what is in the Word of God (or don’t).

      Also, in the thousands of articles I’ve written on the subject, I’ve tried to maintain something of a popular touch and not wax to scholarly. I’d rather put things on a lower shelf and encourage folks to dig deeper. Kinda suits where I’m at myself. Not an expert, but just a fellow who loves our hymnody and doesn’t want it to be forgotten.

      Reply

Leave a Reply to rhwoodman Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *