Skip to content

9 Comments

  1. theshepherdspresence
    14 October 2012 @ 8:27 am

    All of the platform training falls flat if the song is not from the heart. These are good guidelines, but they frighten the humble singer who deeply loves Jesus but does feel he can “measure up.” Balance. It’s all about balance.

    • rcottrill
      14 October 2012 @ 9:20 am

      Thanks for your comments. I certainly agree with your first statement. That’s why I pointed out the need for the individual to be both saved and walking with the Lord, and why I indicated that he or she she should pick songs that relate to their own experience.

      As to whether my article will “frighten humble singers,” in a way I hope it does. Surely it’s a fearful thing to minister for the Lord, to represent Him and claim to be presenting His truth. In some churches, the pendulum may well have swung too far in the other direction, allowing just about anyone who’s willing to serve in this way.

      In speaking of church leadership, the Bible warns against appointing a “novice” (I Tim. 3:6), and says we should “not lay hands [of ordination] on anyone hastily” (I Tim. 5:22). While this is not referring directly to the ministry of music, I believe it can be applied there. In my article Music in the Old Testament, I show the care that was taken to prepare properly for this service.

      One final thought. What’s been laid out in one article might well take months to cover in training sessions. I know in leading choirs I was able, over many weeks, to talk about diction and other matters, and have the choir practice some techniques. I was not intending to imply, “Read my article and you’re ready to sing!”

      If you’re blessed to attend a church with a trained choral group, led by someone who knows what he or she’s doing, these things will all be addressed in their place. And the would-be soloist can be given a short section of a piece, backed by the choir, and gain experience that way.

      Another excellent way for a person to learn these things is at a Bible college with a good music program. Both my wife and I learned a lot that way. I studied both voice and choral conducting, and we both sang in the college chorale.

      These things take time. But maybe that’s the point. And if we believe that only the best is good enough for the Lord, we’ll each strive for excellence, and be willing to keep working toward a higher standard.

  2. Elizabeth
    14 October 2012 @ 7:19 pm

    Great article! I am not a singer, but I still learned from this commentary.

    • rcottrill
      14 October 2012 @ 10:13 pm

      Thanks for your encouragement. Drop by any time.

  3. superkitty1
    15 October 2012 @ 11:31 am

    Thank you for that wonderful and thorough article. All too often, especially when the church is a smaller one, you hear “oh, well, he/she makes a joyful noise, hah, hah”. Makes me wonder who the noise is joyful to – usually not to me and I think that is a slipshod attitude when attempting to use a talent to worship the Lord. I used to be a very good singer, but I am a lot older now and have some medical conditions that make it harder to sing well. I do sing in a small group, although it is not really what one would think of as a choir. I love to sing and sang often with my father who was still singing at the age of 91 when he went to be with the Lord. I used to wish he wouldn’t sing sometimes but he thought he was great and everyone praised him. He once told me “you used to have a good voice – what happened?” I really miss my dad and his commentaries!

    • rcottrill
      15 October 2012 @ 1:00 pm

      Thanks for the wonderful comments. I can identify with what the advancing years do to the voice. Because of some lung problems, I don’t sing solos now as much as I used to. In one church where I was an associate pastor, years go, we had a singing group made up of seniors, which another of the pastors (with an affectionate grin) referred to as “The Scrap-iron Quartet.” Actually, they did very well–and, ironically, the pastor mentioned couldn’t carry a tune at all.

  4. jan
    21 October 2013 @ 3:59 pm

    These are such great truths. The over amplification is really a problem these days in so many churches. You cannot even hear the people sometimes, let alone think about what you are singing. I’ve heard that it is supposed to add “energy” to a room. Well, it sure energized me – to leave! We get enough of this type of thing even at the grocery stores and other shops. One mall nearby has music coming out of speakers in the parking lot. For the cars?? Point being, we don’t need loud accompaniment at church too.

    • rcottrill
      21 October 2013 @ 6:33 pm

      Thanks for your comments. I wrote that article over a year ago, and it was interesting to go back and read it over. I certainly stand by what I said, and your observations about loud music are right on target. Instead of seeking a spiritual response to the message of the words, some church musicians are satisfied with an emotional response to a driving beat, deafening volume or, sometimes, excessive speed. This misses the point by a mile! Thanks again. God bless.

  5. Beatrice T. Jlopleh
    28 July 2017 @ 1:58 pm

    Thanks so much for the information on singing (solo). Music, especially gospel , keeps me in the spirit of worship and really nurtures my soul.