Skip to content

2 Comments

  1. Iggy Antiochus
    5 December 2010 @ 1:42 am

    Random thoughts, trying to keep them on topic…

    The tempo is perfect for the accompaniment, which is nearly flawless. If a flute or other solo instrument played the melody and there were no vocals, I think the tempo would be fine. It would sound like elevator music, though.

    Regarding the tune for “Where He Leads Me,” I would like someone to compose a countermelody for the refrain. Hmm… maybe I should work on that… I find that my ear thinks I am singing twice as many stanzas when the melody for the text is the same as the refrain.

    • rcottrill
      5 December 2010 @ 8:09 am

      H-m-m-… I listened to the video clip again yesterday, and waffled a bit on my original comment. It still does seem a bit…plodding is the best word that comes to mind. It doesn’t feel “gentle” to me. If I were conducting, I think I’d try picking up the pace just a little.

      As to “Where He Leads Me,” I agree. The tune is already somewhat repetitive. To use it for the refrain as well means singing it eight times! What I’ve sometimes done is treat the refrain as a fifth stanza, and sing it only once. But see what you can do with a fresh tune for the refrain. Great idea!