Skip to content

5 Comments

  1. Carol Blair
    29 December 2009 @ 10:32 am

    1. “It Came Upon the Midnight Clear”: I’m fascinated that a song could become a popular Christmas carol even though it never mentions the birth of Christ at all.
    2. P. P. Bliss: What a gift to the Church he was, writing hundreds of hymns, words *and* music to most. The one quoted here is excellent. With “I Will Sing of My Redeemer,” I have often thought that he may have been formulating the music in his mind on that train trip — maybe even writing down some of it – but that music perished in the flames with him. And how bittersweet it must have been for Mr. McGranahan to write the music to his friend’s words – and then later for the assembled group in Chicago to sing the completed hymn.
    3. “Lily of the Valley”: As is the case with so many hymns, this hymn is replete with direct and indirect references to Scripture, and its writer, Charles W. Fry, obviously knew his Bible and his Lord very well. Mr. Fry refers specifically to II Kings 6:17, Rev. 22:16, and Song of Solomon 2:1 and 5:10, and indirectly to Exodus 16:4.

    • rcottrill
      29 December 2009 @ 11:13 am

      Thanks for the excellent comments. As to “It Came Upon the Midnight Clear,” you are right: No direct reference to Christ, or Mary, or Bethlehem, etc. It focuses entirely on the element of promised peace in the message of the angels. Sears was a Unitarian, and that group does not believe in the deity of Christ. However, Edmund Sears apparently had a more orthodox Christology than his fellows. He just doesn’t show it here! “Calm on the Listening Ear of Night” is better in that regard, with…

      Light on thy hills, Jerusalem!
      The Saviour now is born,
      And bright on Bethlehem’s joyous plains
      Breaks the first Christmas morn.

      I might use the first carol occasionally in a carol service, in combination with some that have more explicit teaching (such as “Hark, the Herald Angels Sing”). But to speak of peace and fail to mention the Prince of Peace doesn’t make much sense!

  2. Jon Clayton
    29 December 2010 @ 7:00 pm

    Good stuff Robert. When you get a chance, please read my response to your comment. It will help guide people to your blog. BTW, really nice blog. Happy new year!!

  3. theshepherdspresence
    30 May 2012 @ 8:30 am

    Thank you for your careful research. Bliss wrote songs that spoke to the heart in a deep way. Today ita seems as if the words to worship songs have not the depth of his. This was a fine tribute to Bliss.

    • rcottrill
      30 May 2012 @ 8:59 am

      Thanks for your kind words–and I agree. Though it’s true that there are some trite and shallow old songs, and some strong and inspiring newer songs, it’s generally the case that our traditional hymns and gospel songs speak with far more doctrinal clarity and devotional richness than contemporary songs do.