Skip to content

2 Comments

  1. L tucker
    9 December 2012 @ 1:49 pm

    Do you have or know the original reference for this story? I see it on many websites but no one gives a reference.

    • rcottrill
      10 December 2012 @ 8:34 am

      H-m-m… Interesting question! I’ve been studying our English hymnody and writing about it for many years. Some of the articles were produced for the back of our Sunday bulletin in a church where I was pastor years ago. Others started as newspaper articles. I say that to indicate that I wasn’t doing scholarly, footnoted dissertations. That makes it difficult to go back now and find my sources. There are over seventy books in the blog’s Bibliography, and I’m still adding others–plus research done on the Net, by phone and e-mails.

      All that to say it’s tricky to go back and find sources, though I assure you I try to be as accurate as possible. Many books give biographical details of William Mackay (pronounced Mc-EYE by the Scots). But I notice the full story is found on p. 147 of Then Sings My Soul, by Robert J. Morgan (Thomas Nelson Publishers, 2003). Though Morgan doesn’t identify his source either, it sounds as though the account comes from some kind of memoir written by the doctor himself. (He did write several books.) The account begins: “In his own words, here is the testimony of Scottish doctor W. P. MacKay.”