Skip to content

2 Comments

  1. Carol Blair
    6 March 2010 @ 9:23 am

    I’d be interested to know what you said to the congregation to stop the applause.

    About two years ago another lady in my church and I sang a duet in the morning worship service — one of the arrangements of Psalm 23. The folks at my church had been applauding the special music for quite some time. My duet partner and I agreed that we don’t care for applause, and at the end of my (spoken) introduction to our music, I said, “Because we are singing for the glory of God, we request that there be no applause.”

    There was none that day, but the next Sunday, it was back, and has been every Sunday since. And the more “upbeat” the music, the louder the applause. Including the offertory–the selections for which are becoming more and more jazz-and-rock-infused.

    VERY discouraging.

    • rcottrill
      6 March 2010 @ 10:19 am

      You’re right. It is discouraging. Say what they will, the most common meaning of applause is “Well done! Good job!” But that should not be our primary focus in the house of God. As I’ve said previously, time enough after a service to approach the one who ministered and compliment his/her skill, if we believe that would be an encouragement. Yet even then it would be better to focus on how the ministry blessed us spiritually. The custom of applauding suits a secular concert which is geared to entertaining those who’ve purchased tickets. But a church service is quite different. We are there to praise the Lord, and to learn from His Word. Music should be geared to those twin purposes, and that should be our focus as we listen.

      As to what I said in the incident described, I must admit I was caught off guard. Didn’t expect it. (Much better to do as you did, and make a comment before. Then you can prepare what to say.) I waved my hands with the “No goal!” signal of a hockey referee, and said something like, “I don’t need your applause–unless you’re clapping to thank the Lord for His great love.” I was kind of embarrassed and sad. Strange thoughts went through my mind–like maybe next time I should just read the words, instead of singing them. Then maybe they’d pay attention to the message!

      To some extent, I blame church leadership for the persistence of this habit. It should not be up to singers and instrumentalists to make the point. (Because even in doing so we divert attention from the message of the songs.) There will sometimes be visitors in a service who are used to clapping and may start it off. But the regular congregation should be taught that this is inappropriate. It could be covered in a variety of venues–a church business meeting, Sunday School classes (where discussion of the biblical principles would be appropriate), from the pulpit–even as a sermon topic, by a bulletin insert, or brief instructions in the bulletin. (For example, at the bottom of the order of service at which a soloist will minister, a statement such as: “As the ministry of music is offered to the glory of God, we request that you please refrain from applauding afterward.” Or something like that.)