Skip to content

6 Comments

  1. Carol Blair
    7 January 2010 @ 6:51 pm

    Several years ago I wrote a commentary on the old chorus “Wide, Wide as the Ocean.” Here it is:

    You probably remember this old chorus, but like me, haven’t sung it in years. Maybe decades. I found it in an old hymnbook recently, and the words and music really captured my heart. I caught myself singing it many times over the next few days, as well as thinking about the theology, and the poetry, and the music.

    Wide, wide as the ocean, High as the Heaven above;
    Deep, deep as the deepest sea Is my Saviour’s love.
    I, though so unworthy, Still am a child of His care;
    For His Word teaches me
    That His love reaches me
    Everywhere.

    The theology is excellent. (Based on Psalm 139 and Romans 8:35-39) So is the poetry (note the word arrangement, rhyme scheme, symmetry, and balance, above). And the music beautifully complements the theology and the words, with the high point being the word “everywhere”–thus creating an
    eminently singable Gospel song.

    • rcottrill
      7 January 2010 @ 7:55 pm

      I agree. Some of these little choruses seem to be mindless ditties that we can well do without. Climb, Climb Up Sunshine Mountain will not teach children any important truths of God’s Word–even if it is explained, if it indeed can be! But Wide, Wide As the Ocean is different. You suggest a couple of Scriptures that may relate. But to me it seems to be based on Ephesians 3:17-19, and it helps to give us a picture of the infinite love of the Lord.

  2. Robert H. Woodman
    26 June 2010 @ 10:07 pm

    I checked out your link for “Today in 1838” that you referenced above, and I got a 404 “File Not Found” error. Would you mind relinking the file so that I can read that other hymn, please?

    Thanks!

    By the way, “Oh How I Love Jesus” just drives me nuts because it is so theologically vapid. “I Saw the Cross of Jesus” moves me. I guess no hymn writer can hit a home run with every outing. 🙂

    • rcottrill
      27 June 2010 @ 7:43 am

      Thanks for catching that. I’ve been moving some former blogs and updating the information, and it gets a little complicated! See if you can open the linked file now. It’s actually dated to appear as a blog in a couple of weeks (July 9), but I’m hoping it will work as a link until then. (I’m still learning!) Let me know if it’s not accessible now. I may have to give the process more thought and study.

      As to your comment: No, even our greatest hymn and gospel song writers had some poorly written numbers, or ones that have fallen by the wayside for other reasons. Charles Wesley’s “Ah, Lovely Appearance of Death!” may be of historical interest, but it’s morbid in the extreme!

      Ah, lovely appearance of death!
      What sight upon earth is so fair?
      Not all the gay pageants that breathe
      Can with a dead body compare.

      • Robert H. Woodman
        27 June 2010 @ 10:00 pm

        Nope. Still not working.

        As to Wesley’s “Ah, Lovely Appearance of Death!” can you tell me why he wrote that hymn? It does indeed sound morbid!

        • rcottrill
          28 June 2010 @ 8:45 am

          A young fellow died in Cardiff, Wales, in August of 1744. Apparently Wesley wrote “Ah, Lovely Appearance of Death” as a funeral hymn. He called it “On the Sight of a Corpse,” and wrote in his Journal, “The spirit at its departure had left marks of its happiness on the clay. No sight upon earth, in my eyes, is half so lovely.” For your interest, here’s the entire hymn.

          Ah lovely appearance of death!
          No sight upon earth is so fair;
          Not all the gay pageants that breathe
          Can with a dead body compare:
          With solemn delight I survey
          The corpse when the spirit is fled,
          In love with the beautiful clay,
          And longing to lie in its stead.

          How blest is our brother, bereft
          Of all that could burthen his mind,
          How easy the soul that hath left
          This wearisom body behind!
          Of evil incapable thou,
          Whose relicks with envy I see,
          No longer in misery now,
          No longer a sinner like me.

          This earth is affected no more
          With sickness, or shaken with pain,
          The war in the members is o’er,
          And never shall vex him again:
          No anger henceforward, or shame,
          Shall redden this innocent clay,
          Extinct is the animal flame,
          And passion is vanish’d away.

          The languishing head is at rest,
          Its thinking and aching are o’er,
          The quiet immovable breast
          Is heav’d by affliction no more:
          The heart is no longer the seat
          Of trouble and torturing pain,
          It ceases to flutter and beat,
          It never shall flutter again.

          The lids he so seldom could close,
          By sorrow forbidden to sleep,
          Seal’d up in eternal repose,
          Have strangely forgotten to weep:
          The fountains can yield no supplies,
          These hollows from water are free,
          The tears are all wip’d from these eyes,
          And evil they never shall see.

          To mourn, and to suffer, is mine,
          While bound in a prison I breathe,
          And still for deliverance pine,
          And press to the issues of death:
          What now with my tears I bedew,
          O might I this moment become,
          My spirit created a-new,
          My flesh be consign’d to the tomb.