Skip to content

4 Comments

  1. Carol Blair
    31 October 2010 @ 7:00 am

    1. With Wordsworth’s hymn, second verse: I have never before realized the significance of the Lord’s Day in relation to each Person of the Trinity. And with all I’ve heard and read about the Sabbath and the 4th Commandment, this point has never been mentioned.

    2. With his 6th-grade education, Andrew Skoog’s poetry composition skills are far superior to the skills of today’s “hymn” writers.

    3. I am writing this on the 31st. Happy Reformation Day! May Luther’s greatest hymn by sung by all this morning — all 4 verses, of course. For those who have never memorized a hymn, here is a good place to start.

    • rcottrill
      31 October 2010 @ 7:29 am

      Thanks for your comments. I quite agree with your second point. In so many cases, not only has any pattern of rhyming been abandoned, the words do not fit the metre of the tune, and must be scrunched in here and there to fit.

      And Wordsworth’s stanza about the triple significance of the Lord’s Day is beautiful. However, I part company with those who believe the Jewish Sabbath has somehow been moved from Saturday to Sunday. The Sabbath and the Lord’s Day are quite different days, distinct in origin and purpose. (Readers can check out my article on the “Sunday Sabbath” to see my reasons for this conviction.)

      On your latter point, I don’t think “A Mighty Fortress” is in our Order of Service for today. We do sing it quite often however, and it is indeed a great hymn.

  2. William A. Moline
    14 October 2011 @ 3:23 pm

    AL Skoog is an ancestor of mine, my maternal grandmother’s cousin. Day By Day is our family’s unofficial family hymn. I think his words are wonderful. If you have any more information on him, i would appreciate hearing from you. (wamoline@yahoo.com).

    • rcottrill
      14 October 2011 @ 5:25 pm

      Thanks for the interesting background. I’m assuming you have pictures of Mr. Skoog. If not, you can see a couple on the Cyber Hymnal, here. (Quite an impressive moustache!)