Skip to content

4 Comments

  1. Carol Blair
    6 January 2012 @ 10:28 am

    I’ve been thinking about this hymn, “One Day,” plus three others, all of which tell the whole story of the life of Jesus. The other three are
    — Tell Me the Story of Jesus
    — Thou Didst Leave Thy Throne
    — Who Is He in Yonder Stall?
    I love all of these because they tell the “complete story,” beginning with the birth of Christ, then including His death for our sins, His burial, and His Resurrection. But what is interesting to me is that the last two are considered to be Christmas carols, but the first two are not. I don’t see anything significant that would support this delineation. Thoughts? And are there any other hymns that I have not named that tell the whole story of Jesus?
    BTW, I *love* “Thou Didst Leave . . .” and “Who Is He . . .” — neither of which is well known, and neither of which have I sung in a long time. I lament this lack!
    (I hope that because I am commenting on an “old” post that my comment will not be “missed.”)

    • rcottrill
      6 January 2012 @ 11:08 am

      No problem commenting on “old posts.” Because of the indexing and the subject matter, I can get comments on any of the over a thousand hymns I’ve blogged about since May of 2009. I try to respond to pretty well all of them–unless they’re spam, or totally dumb.

      As to your question, I’m not sure why some songs about the birth of Christ didn’t end up being called carols. The list of older traditional carols is pretty well established. But there are newer ones too, such as “Come on, Ring Those Bells” (1976), and “Mary, Did You Know?” (1984).

      In my book, Discovering the Songs of Christmas, I avoided the word “carols” in the title because I wanted to deal with the kind of hymns you’re talking about, ones that deal with Christmas in the context of the broader life of Christ. Each of the ones you’ve mentioned is in my book: One Day; Tell Me the Story of Jesus; Thou Didst Leave Thy Throne; and Who Is He in Yonder Stall. Songs such as “That Beautiful Name,” and Benson’s “O Sing a Song of Bethlehem” also go beyond the incarnation to talk about the cross and more.

      Thanks for writing. God bless.

  2. Abby
    27 March 2013 @ 9:54 pm

    This hymn is a favorite of my husband’s as it sums up the whole story in one hymn or even yet, the chorus of the song. As a pianist, I think it interesting that the author handed his text to the organist who then wrote a tune for it. Fascinating. I’ve written about this hymn on my blog today and have linked back to your post here. Thanks so much for your ministry. It is greatly appreciated.

    • rcottrill
      28 March 2013 @ 7:57 am

      Thank you Abby for your kind words. As to the hymn, there are a number that cover many key events in the life of Christ, as One Day does. (Wounded for Me is another.) I suspect that many churches that still use hymns and hymn books (bless them!) will sing Dr. Chapman’s hymn this week. God bless, and all the joys of Easter to you and your husband.