Skip to content

7 Comments

  1. iggyantiochus
    8 June 2011 @ 7:41 am

    Chanticleer does and excellent setting of the text, “Am I a Soldier of the Cross” in a-capella gospel style that begins with the song leader saying, “Hymn 414 set to the common meter.” 🙂

    • rcottrill
      8 June 2011 @ 8:12 am

      Great to hear from you. I had hopes that maybe this version of the hymn was posted on YouTube, but it’s not. I contented myself with listening to their rendition of Shenandoah. Wow! Stunning! As one who sang in a male chorus about half a century ago, I can appreciate the blending of talent and hard work that goes into their performances. God bless.

      • iggyantiochus
        8 June 2011 @ 5:35 pm

        It’s outside of both our traditions, but the Biebl setting of Ave Maria is really wonderful. The verses recount the Annunciation of Our Lord to Mary. Sadly, the refrain is half Scripture and half tradition. I know of one institution that corrected the refrain sang it in English! http://youtu.be/XVyCJlPiHFg

        • rcottrill
          9 June 2011 @ 8:05 am

          H-m-m… Well, as to the music, the Biebl setting is well-performed by Chanticleer, but I prefer Schubert’s or Gounod’s music. A personal taste thing, but Franz Biebl’s version seems rather meandering and tuneless to me, a bit like a Gregorian Chant. It’s what one’s used to, I guess. The beauty of the other two compositions always leaves me wishing they could be detached from their Romish text, and used in other ways, but the association is too strong. Too many listeners would immediately wonder why the organist is playing Ave Maria in an evangelical Protestant church. 🙂

          As I understand it, Biebl’s text combines Ave Maria with the Angelus and, in the translation I hunted up, a lot of it is scriptural. But of course asking the “Mother of God” to pray for us, “now and in the hour of our death,” is definitely not. It not only exalts Mary to a position God has not given her, but it discounts the eternal sufficiency of the intercessory work of Christ (Heb. 7:25).

  2. iggyantiochus
    9 June 2011 @ 6:56 pm

    I like the Gounod setting, with the melody set against Bach’s prelude. Don’t care for the Shubert, mostly because it is overdone. In Biebl’s arrangement, the Gregorian style of the verses are contrasted with the 8-part male chorus for the refrain. Of course, it’s the 2nd part of the refrain where things get real sticky!

  3. Joyously Saved
    31 May 2012 @ 3:35 pm

    I was so pleased to come upon your blog today! “Am I A Soldier of the Cross” is one of my favorite hymns as I feel I have been led to lift up the names and identities of the forgotten Reformation era martyrs. Great job, and I’ll be returning!

    • rcottrill
      31 May 2012 @ 4:16 pm

      Thanks for your encouragement, and for the work you’re doing. We sometimes forget how much others have gone through to preserve the apostolic faith “once for all delivered to the saints.” God bless.