Skip to content

13 Comments

  1. Dr.Thomas Iype
    15 July 2009 @ 8:10 pm

    What an amazing and encouraging song and story!–which I used to quote in my sermons.

    • rcottrill
      15 July 2009 @ 10:42 pm

      Yes, I agree. And there are a number of instances when hymn writers have been significantly impacted by listening to their own songs. D. R. van Sickle was not a Christian. But he claimed that anybody could write a hymn, even him. And he did. He wrote:

      All hail to Thee, Immanuel,
      We cast our crowns before Thee;
      Let every heart obey Thy will,
      And every voice adore Thee.
      In praise to Thee, our Saviour King,
      The vibrant chords of heaven ring,
      And echo back the mighty strain,
      All hail! Immanuel!

      All hail to Thee, Immanuel,
      Our risen King and Saviour!
      Thy foes are vanquished,
      And Thou art omnipotent forever.
      Death, sin and hell no longer reign,
      And Satan’s power is burst in twain;
      Eternal glory to Thy name:
      All hail! Immanuel!

      But God is not mocked. Years later, he came under conviction and was brought to Christ when visiting a church and listening to his own song sung by the choir!

  2. andrewalma
    5 September 2009 @ 12:49 am

    Thanks for your words about “Come Thou Fount of Every Blessing.” I am the person who blogged about singing that and other songs to the inmates at the prison. I’ll share Robert Robinson’s story with my friends.

    • rcottrill
      5 September 2009 @ 7:57 am

      Thanks Andrew. I actually heard from a prison chaplain one time that stories about some of the inmates’ favourite hymns were a great blessing. Maybe you could use the story that way. It has to do with repentance and redemption, a much needed theme behind prison walls.

  3. David Potter
    9 June 2010 @ 11:31 am

    What an amazing story of God’s faithfulness to His children, even in our stubborn disobedience. As you know, I recently posted a simply acoustic arrangement of this hymn on my site, davidpottermusic.wordpress.com.

    • rcottrill
      9 June 2010 @ 11:51 am

      Thanks for your comments. Yes, God’s faithfulness, and certainly His mercy and grace are in view, in dealing with His wayward child.

  4. alex dahn
    2 July 2013 @ 12:35 pm

    Personally I have such difficulties with the Mormons’ heretical ‘faith’ that I wouldn’t listen to their choir or anything from them at all !!

    • rcottrill
      2 July 2013 @ 2:37 pm

      I do agree with your view of Mormonism, though I enjoy music that’s well done. You’ll be happy to see that because of copyright the video clip has been pulled from the site.

  5. Dominic
    28 July 2013 @ 12:23 am

    Dear Mr. Cottrill,
    I have heard the story of Robert Robinson a number of times (of him being backslidden and riding in a coach with a woman who was reading his hymn), but I have been unable to verify that he really did this and that he fell into a life of sin. Dominic

    • rcottrill
      28 July 2013 @ 6:59 am

      As you can see, many of the details you mention are in the article I posted. I’ve got many resources that tell basically the same story, so yes, I do believe it’s accurate. You do raise a good point though: how we can be certain of things that happened so long ago. In many cases, data comes from journals and autobiographies of the individuals themselves, or from material written by their acquaintances, or others closer to the time. I do my best to track down the information. Sometimes, readers send comments that help.

  6. Hanna
    27 October 2015 @ 12:31 pm

    I was wondering if you have cited your resources for accuracy? I can’t see them, but maybe I’m missing them. I do love the idea of the story, whether it’s historically accurate or not.

    • rcottrill
      27 October 2015 @ 1:49 pm

      It’s a good question. Actually, all the seventy plus books listed in the Bibliography and more have been used in research for the articles on the blog, but I haven’t always taken the extra time required to pinpoint what particular information came from where.

      The initial comment of Robinson about wishing he felt as he had years ago when he wrote the hymn is well documented. And a number of sources refer to his later repentance. As to the part the young woman had in that, I can’t recall where I saw that, but I notice Paul Lee Tan refers to it in his Encyclopedia of 7700 Illustrations (Assurance Publishers, 1979, p. 183).

  7. Anne
    23 June 2018 @ 6:51 pm

    Not long before my wonderful beloved Peter went to sleep in Jesus, he didnt feel well enough to play the church organ on one particular Sunday morning, so asked me if I could take his place. I heartily agreed and he showed me the list of songs to play. But I didn’t know “Come, Thou Fount of Every Blessing.” So Peter taught me the hymn. Now whenever I hear the song I can’t stop crying, and always think of Peter and hear his voice teaching me the song all over again.