Skip to content

7 Comments

  1. Brian
    1 February 2012 @ 9:26 pm

    Thanks for stopping by my blog today! I’ve recently moved to attend seminary, so my time is crunched with greek verbs and writings of old dead guys so I’m not able to regularly post on the site right now. I hope to be more active this summer.

    Even if you don’t like indelible grace’s tunes to old hymns, at least we can share a love for an old lyric that expresses praise, honor and worship to our wonderful creator and sustainer…

    • rcottrill
      2 February 2012 @ 9:08 am

      H-m-m… Agreed that we can share for the message of the great hymns of the faith. I do, every day, as I work with them, and they often bless my socks off. 🙂 However, the music of our hymns is intended to provide an appropriate frame for which the text is the picture. To frame superb words with carnal bedlam that appeals to the flesh does not enhance their message; it detracts from it by drawing inordinate attention to itself. I’m not against instrumental accompaniment, if it truly accompanies, and doesn’t dominate the experience.

      Having said that, I must add that some of the most blessed and glorious hymn-singing in which I’ve ever participated has been unaccompanied. We’re able to hear one another, and it becomes a true fellowship in song. Parts-singing enhances the melody in that shared experience, and the message of the text seems to come through naturally, and often powerfully.

      One quick example that I came across on YouTube. Don’t know the group. They seem to be a mix of ages, but mostly youth and young adults. There is accompaniment at the beginning, but it seems to drop out somewhere along the way. It also interested me that the accompanists were behind the congregation. In that way they’d be less of a distraction. Too many “worship teams” give the impression that “it’s all about us.” Anyway, just a personal opinion: I find this soul-stirring.
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=D1BI-iEcF4Q

      God bless.

  2. Carol Blair
    4 February 2012 @ 12:51 pm

    Robert, I agree completely with your thoughts here.

    And this video — what a wonderful church, where *everyone* is singing! “The Son of God Goes Forth to War” is not a well-known hymn, because its theme (martyrdom) is so daunting. I have never heard the tune they are using, but apparently they know it well.

    • rcottrill
      4 February 2012 @ 1:15 pm

      Thank you so much for your encouraging note. I’m really struggling this morning–health problems, and work load, and so on. It was so good to “hear” a friendly voice.

      I agree, it’s wonderful to hear a congregation really sing! I’ve had the experience of being part of such groups a few times in my life, and I treasure the memory. The trend seems to be for some band to make lots of noise on the platform, while the people of God mumble along–often trying valantly to sing tuneless songs with repetitious words, and metres that don’t scan properly! There now! You can tell I’m in a rather negative mood! Better leave well enough alone, before I say something really controversial! 🙂

  3. Marian
    12 February 2012 @ 3:04 pm

    Hymnary.org lists that “Old Norman Melody” as Towner because it was harmonized by Danile B. Towner in 1909. But maybe you already knew that.

    • rcottrill
      12 February 2012 @ 3:21 pm

      Yes, I do indeed know that. But there’s also another tune named Towner, here, and I was trying to avoid further confusion! I do wish the tune I mentioned had a more precise identification, as it’s a fine one, with a good refrain.

  4. Marian
    12 February 2012 @ 3:19 pm

    Oh, and that video–Cornerstone Reformed Church in Carbondale. Check out their other YouTube videos or their website http://www.cornerstonecrec.org/ Looks like a fun church to attend. Too bad I don’t live in Carbondale.